Phone accommodations for hard of hearing employees
Phone accommodations for hard of hearing employees: your rights, tools to ask for, a sample request, and options if you're your own boss.
Meetings have slides and chat. Email is just text. The phone is different: one voice, no face, often a noisy line, and a customer who reads out an order number once at full speed. For many people with hearing loss, the phone is the part of the job that gets hard first.
If that’s you, you don’t have to just put up with it. Here are the phone accommodations hard of hearing employees can ask for, how to ask, and what to do if there’s no employer to ask because you run the business.
Why the phone is often the hardest part
On a call you lose lip reading and facial expressions, the sound is squeezed into a narrow band, and you get the noise at both ends. We go into the reasons, and how they differ by type of hearing loss, in hearing loss and phone calls: why the type matters.
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) uses exactly this situation as an example: an employee making mistakes in customer orders she takes over the phone. Its suggested accommodations are a captioned telephone, so she can talk while reading a real-time text of the conversation, or technology that streams the call to her hearing aid (EEOC).
Your rights, in plain terms
In the U.S., the employment part of the Americans with Disabilities Act (Title I) applies to employers with 15 or more employees, including state and local governments, employment agencies and labor unions (ADA.gov). Some state laws also cover smaller employers, and federal employees are covered by a similar law, Section 501 of the Rehabilitation Act (EEOC).
From the EEOC’s guidance on hearing disabilities at work (EEOC):
- There are no “magic words.” You only have to tell your employer that you need an adjustment or change at work because of your hearing loss. You don’t have to say “reasonable accommodation” or cite the law.
- It’s a conversation. If your employer needs more information, it should talk it through with you, which the EEOC calls an “interactive process.”
- Your preference counts, but it isn’t a veto. If more than one accommodation would work, your preference should be given primary consideration, but your employer doesn’t have to give you your first choice. If what you ask for is too difficult or expensive, it can offer an easier or cheaper option, as long as that one works for you.
- There are limits. An employer doesn’t have to provide an accommodation that would mean significant difficulty or expense (an “undue hardship”), or remove an essential part of the job.
- Personal items aren’t included. Employers don’t have to provide things like hearing aids that you use on and off the job. But equipment you need for the job, like a hearing aid compatible headset or a captioned phone, is on the EEOC’s list of possible accommodations.
This is general information, not legal advice. If a request goes badly, the EEOC’s page explains how to file a charge, and the deadlines are short: generally 180 days from what happened, or 300 days where a state or local law also covers the employer. Federal employees have a different process and must contact their agency’s EEO counselor, generally within 45 days.
Phone accommodations worth asking for
The Job Accommodation Network (JAN), a free, confidential service the EEOC points employers to, lists these among its phone ideas for people with hearing loss, under “Phone Access” and “Phone Technology” (JAN), and the EEOC lists several of them too (EEOC):
- Captioned telephone calls. You talk and listen as usual and read captions of what the other person says. The internet-based version, IP CTS, also comes in versions for a smartphone or a computer, and the FCC notes it helps people use the phone “in their jobs” (FCC). It’s a form of relay service, and relay providers are paid from a state or federal fund (FCC).
- A hearing aid compatible or amplified headset, or a telephone amplifier.
- Streaming calls to your hearing aids. Many smartphones can send calls straight to Bluetooth hearing aids, sometimes through an app (HLAA).
- Voice carry-over (VCO), if you speak for yourself but need to read the other side, or a TTY or TTY software if you’d rather type.
- Voicemail transcription, so messages arrive as text instead of audio you have to replay.
Bring your audiologist into it. They know which of these works with your hearing aids or implant. And if your employer asks for documentation, which it can when your hearing loss isn’t obvious, a short note from them covers it (EEOC).
Changing how the job uses the phone
Equipment isn’t the only option. JAN also lists job restructuring (JAN). For the phone, that can mean:
- Moving routine calls to email, chat or a web form where it makes no difference to the customer.
- Written follow-up of anything exact: order numbers, dates, addresses, prices.
- Scheduled calls instead of surprise ones, so you can take them somewhere quiet with the right setup.
- Trading the hardest calls, such as a noisy hotline, for other work with a colleague, if those calls aren’t a core part of your job.
How to ask, with a sample
Keep it short and concrete. Name the task, what makes it hard, and what you’d like to try. Put it in writing so there’s a record.
Hi [manager],
My hearing loss makes some phone calls hard to follow, especially customer calls on noisy lines, and I'm worried about mistakes in orders and callback numbers.
I'd like to ask for an accommodation. A captioned phone service on my work line would let me read what callers say while I talk with them. A hearing aid compatible headset would also help.
Can we talk this week about what would work?
Thanks,
[name]
Employers often expect accommodations to be expensive. JAN’s survey of employers it has worked with, across all disabilities, says otherwise: of 1,425 employers who reported costs, 61% said their accommodations cost nothing, and 33% had a one-time cost with a median of $300 (JAN). If either of you is stuck, JAN gives free, confidential advice to employees and employers alike.
If you’re self-employed or the boss
Freelancers, contractors and small business owners have no employer to ask, and the calls are often the business itself. You choose your own setup:
- Captioned telephone service. If you’re eligible, IP CTS can run on a smartphone or computer (FCC).
- Captioning apps. There are captioning apps for Android and iPhone that work on phone calls (HLAA).
- A separate work number. Work calls stop competing with personal ones, and you can decide when they ring through and when they go to something that answers for you.
- Ask for it in writing. Tell customers to email the details or send them by form, and read numbers back before you hang up.
A checklist for phone calls at work
- List the phone tasks in your job, and mark which ones are hardest to hear.
- Talk to your audiologist about what works with your hearing aids or implant.
- Pick one or two tools to try first: captions, a headset, streaming or transcribed voicemail.
- Ask in writing, with the task, the problem and what you’d like.
- Get the exact details in writing: numbers, dates and addresses, read back or followed up by email.
- Review after a month, and ask again if it isn’t working.
Where Redtie fits, and what it isn’t
Redtie is a phone line in an app, designed first for people who are deaf or hard of hearing. For work calls it gives you:
- A separate work number in the area code you choose, or forward your own existing number to it.
- Two-way live captions. Both sides of the call appear as text while you talk, labelled by speaker.
- An AI assistant for the calls you don’t want to take live. It answers, asks who’s calling and what they need, reads the callback number back, and sends you a written summary. In the desktop app (Mac or Windows) you can follow the call as captions and take it over at any point.
- A transcript of every call, so you can go back and check what was said.
What it isn’t:
- It isn’t an FCC-certified captioned telephone service. If you’re eligible for IP CTS and it works for you, try it first.
- It isn’t a medical device or a hearing aid, and it doesn’t replace a hearing evaluation.
- It doesn’t plug into your employer’s phone system. It’s its own number, which suits freelancers and owners more than employees on a company switchboard.
- It’s for calls. It doesn’t text your customers or transfer callers to a colleague.
- It isn’t an emergency phone. It may not support 911 or other emergency calls, so keep your regular phone, and any relay service you use, for emergencies.
- It’s a paid line, with a 7-day free trial.
- The captions come from speech recognition, which can mis-hear names, numbers and noisy lines. That’s why the assistant reads callback numbers back, and why the transcript is there to check.
Start with the calls that matter most
Pick the one kind of call that causes you the most trouble at work, and fix that first. Whether it’s a captioned phone from your employer or a line of your own, the goal is the same: get it right the first time, and have it in writing afterwards.
This isn't legal or medical advice. It's general information. For your own situation, talk to your employer's HR team, JAN or a lawyer, and to an audiologist about your hearing.
Sources
- Hearing Disabilities in the Workplace and the Americans with Disabilities Act — U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
- Introduction to the Americans with Disabilities Act — U.S. Department of Justice, ADA.gov
- A to Z of disabilities and accommodations: hearing — Job Accommodation Network (JAN)
- Costs and Benefits of Accommodation — Job Accommodation Network (JAN)
- Internet Protocol (IP) Captioned Telephone Service — Federal Communications Commission (FCC)
- Consumer Guide: Telecommunications Relay Service - TRS — Federal Communications Commission (FCC)
- Phones and Mobile Devices — Hearing Loss Association of America (HLAA)