Medicare open enrollment calls: how to tell real from scam
Medicare open enrollment scam calls: what Medicare does and doesn't do by phone, the scripts to listen for, and how to help a parent stay safe.
The phone rings in the middle of the afternoon. The caller says they’re from Medicare. They’re friendly. They already know your name. They say there’s a new card coming, and they just need to confirm your Medicare number first.
It sounds routine. It’s a scam. And this time of year, there are a lot more calls like it.
This guide is for two people: anyone on Medicare, and the son or daughter who helps a parent with the phone. It covers what Medicare does and doesn’t do by phone, the scripts to listen for, what to do on the call, and how to set things up together so the next one is easier.
Why the calls pick up now
Medicare Open Enrollment runs from October 15 to December 7 each year. This year that’s October 15 to December 7, 2026. It’s when you can switch Medicare Advantage or drug plans, or move between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage. Changes start on January 1, as long as the plan gets your request by December 7 (Medicare.gov).
Scammers know everyone is thinking about Medicare right now, so they pose as Medicare to get your information (FTC). The Senior Medicare Patrol also warns that open enrollment brings more calls and marketing in general, including agents using misleading tactics to get you to switch plans (SMP).
What Medicare does, and doesn’t do, by phone
This is the part to remember. Write it down if it helps.
- Medicare won’t call you out of the blue to ask for personal information. That includes your Medicare number, your Social Security number and your bank account (Medicare.gov, FTC).
- Medicare won’t call to sell you anything, and won’t visit your home (Medicare.gov).
- Medicare only calls and asks for personal information in a few limited cases, like returning your call after you left a message, reported fraud or joined a plan (Medicare.gov). In other words, you started the conversation.
- Medicare cards are free and mailed automatically. Nobody needs to “verify” your number before one arrives, and there’s no fee (FTC, FTC).
- Medicare won’t call to threaten your coverage. If a caller says you’ll lose your benefits or asks for money, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself (Medicare.gov, FTC).
Medicare’s own advice is simple: protect your Medicare number like a credit card. Share it only with your doctors and other providers, your insurance company or plan (and its licensed agents), or people you trust who work with Medicare, like your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP). Don’t give it to anyone who contacts you first, unless you reached out to them and said they could call (Medicare.gov).
The scripts to listen for
The details change, but the shape is the same: an unexpected call, a reason you need to act, and a request for your number or your money. These are the ones the FTC and the Senior Medicare Patrol warn about.
- “Your new Medicare card is ready.” The caller needs your Medicare number, bank account or card number for a “new” or “updated” card. Real cards are free and come in the mail (FTC). Some callers even promise a new plastic card; Medicare cards are paper (FTC).
- “We just need to verify your identity.” Medicare won’t call to verify your card (FTC).
- “There’s a claim for medical equipment.” The caller says they need your number for an equipment claim you don’t remember. The goal is to use your number to bill Medicare for things you never got (FTC). Unexpected calls offering braces and other equipment fit the same pattern (FTC).
- “You qualify for a free genetic test.” A call about a “free” test is one of the red flags the Senior Medicare Patrol lists (SMP).
- “Your coverage will be canceled.” A threat to your benefits, often with a fee to fix it (FTC).
Once a scammer has your Medicare number and other details, they can commit identity fraud and file bogus claims in your name (SMP).
Don’t trust the caller ID
The screen might say “Medicare”. It might show a local number. Neither tells you who is calling. Caller ID can show any name or number a scammer picks; it’s called spoofing (FTC). The FTC warns not to trust caller ID even when it shows Medicare’s own number (FTC).
A caller who sounds professional, or who already knows some of your details, isn’t proof either (FTC).
What to do on the call
You don’t have to figure out whether the caller is real. You only have to end the call and check for yourself.
- Hang up. It’s not rude. A real Medicare question will still be there when you call back.
- Don’t give your Medicare number, Social Security number or bank details to anyone who called you (FTC).
- Call Medicare yourself at 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048 (Medicare.gov). Dial the number yourself. Don’t use one the caller gave you.
- Don’t pay over the phone. Scammers often ask for wire transfers, gift cards, cryptocurrency or payment apps, because that money is hard to get back (FTC).
- For plan questions, ask someone neutral. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) gives free help comparing plans (FTC, SMP).
How to report it
Even if you hung up in time, a report helps.
- Medicare: call 1-800-MEDICARE. You can also report Medicare fraud online through the HHS Office of Inspector General, linked from Medicare’s fraud page (Medicare.gov).
- The FTC: report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov (FTC).
- Your Senior Medicare Patrol: call the SMP toll-free line at 877-808-2468, or use the report form at smpresource.org (SMP).
- Medicare Advantage or drug plan fraud: call I-MEDIC at 1-877-7SAFERX (1-877-772-3379) (Medicare.gov).
If you think you already gave out your number, check your Medicare statements against the care you actually got, and look for visits, double charges or equipment you don’t recognize. Call your doctor or plan about anything that looks wrong (FTC).
If you’re helping a parent
Most of this works best done together, before the next call, not during it.
- Sit down for half an hour. Go through what Medicare does and doesn’t do by phone. Keep it calm. The point isn’t “you’ll get scammed”. It’s “here’s an easy rule”.
- Write the real numbers on paper. 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), your parent’s plan, their doctor, their pharmacy and your own number. Put the sheet by the phone. When a caller says “call us back at this number”, your parent uses the sheet instead.
- Agree on one rule. “If anyone calls about Medicare, I hang up and call the number on the sheet, or I call you.” One rule is easier to keep than a list of red flags.
- Save the people who matter as contacts. Doctors, the pharmacy, the plan, family and neighbors. Then an unfamiliar number stands out more.
- Look at the statements together. A quick look at each Medicare statement can catch a bill for something your parent never got (FTC).
- Get permission to talk to Medicare. If you want Medicare to share your parent’s health information with you, your parent needs to fill out an “Authorization to Disclose Personal Health Information” form (Medicare.gov).
- No shame if it happened. These callers are practiced. If your parent shared a number, report it and check the statements. That’s it.
For more on how phone scams work in general, and what helps, read worn out by scam calls?
Where Redtie fits
Redtie is a phone line with an AI assistant built in. Each line has a setting called Callers not in your contacts. Set it to Send to the assistant, and people you know ring through as usual: your saved contacts, numbers you’ve called from that line in the last 30 days, and verified cell numbers. Other callers are answered by the assistant. It takes a message and emails you a summary, so you can read what the caller wanted and decide later, calmly, whether to call back on a number you trust. The announcement has the details.
It helps screen calls. It doesn’t decide whether a caller is a scammer, and a scammer can still leave a message. Because caller ID can be faked, a call that shows a number in your contacts still rings through.
Some honest limits:
- It’s a separate Redtie number, not the number your parent has now. It helps most on a number you give to family, doctors and the plan.
- New callers meet the assistant first. A new doctor’s office or a plan calling back from an unknown number gets the assistant. Save those numbers as contacts.
- It may not support 911 or other emergency calls (terms). Keep a regular phone for emergencies.
The short version
Medicare won’t call you out of the blue for your Medicare number, a payment or a “new card”. If a call asks for any of those, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself. Report it. And if you’re helping a parent, sit down together, write the real numbers on paper, and agree on one simple rule.
See how Redtie works as a second phone number, or read should you answer calls from unknown numbers? There’s a 7-day free trial when you sign up on the web.
Sources
- Open Enrollment — Medicare.gov
- Your Medicare card — Medicare.gov
- Reporting Medicare fraud & abuse — Medicare.gov
- Contact Medicare — Medicare.gov
- This Medicare Open Enrollment season, learn how to protect yourself from scams — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Avoid scams during Medicare's Open Enrollment Period — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- How to avoid Medicare Open Enrollment scams — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Your Medicare number is valuable. Protect it — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Spot Health Insurance Scams — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Phone Scams — Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- Medicare Open Enrollment is happening! Watch out for misleading marketing. — Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP Resource Center)
- Watch Out for Medicare Scams — Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP Resource Center)
- Red Flags of Medicare Fraud — Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP Resource Center)